American banks are currently facing numerous challenges, including the surge in interest rates, which has led to shrinking margins and increasing loan losses. These difficulties have raised concerns within the industry, but some analysts believe there may be a silver lining amidst the woes. This article will explore the impact of higher interest rates on banks’ earnings and balance sheets, as well as the potential opportunities that could arise from these challenges.
Just as it occurred during the regional banking crisis in March, higher interest rates are anticipated to result in losses on banks’ bond portfolios and additional funding pressures. Analysts from KBW estimate that banks’ per-share earnings fell by 18% in the third quarter due to compressed lending margins and a decline in loan demand caused by higher borrowing costs. The decline in revenues and margins, along with slower growth, present a challenging near-term outlook for the industry.
The performance of bank stocks has been heavily influenced by the path of borrowing costs throughout the year. In September, the S&P 500 Banks index experienced a significant decrease of 9.3% due to concerns sparked by a surprising surge in longer-term interest rates, particularly the 10-year yield. Rising yields led to a decline in the value of bonds owned by banks, resulting in unrealized losses that put pressure on capital levels. Midsized institutions like Silicon Valley Bank and First Republic were caught off guard earlier this year, leading to government seizure of these banks. However, big banks, with the exception of Bank of America, have largely avoided major concerns related to underwater bonds.
Analysts have different expectations regarding the impact of higher rates on banks’ balance sheets. Morgan Stanley analysts predict that the estimated impact from the bond rout in the third quarter will be more than double the losses experienced in the second quarter. Regional lenders, such as Comerica, Fifth Third Bank, and KeyBank, are expected to be the most affected by bond losses. However, other analysts, including KBW and UBS, believe that other factors may mitigate the capital hit for most banks. The duration of banks’ bond holdings will play a significant role in determining the extent of the impact. Banks with shorter-term bond holdings may experience similar bond marks as in the previous quarter, while a smaller group of banks may be hit harder based on the composition of their portfolios.
There is also concern that higher interest rates will result in increased losses in commercial real estate and industrial loans. RBC analyst Gerard Cassidy anticipates a significant increase in loan loss provisions compared to the third quarter of 2022 as banks build up reserves. These potential loan losses add another layer of challenge for banks during this period.
Despite these challenges, there is potential for a short squeeze in bank stocks during earnings season. Hedge funds have placed bets on a return of the chaos witnessed in March when regional banks experienced deposit outflows. Analysts from UBS believe that the combination of high short interest levels and the belief that higher rates will trigger another liquidity crisis could lead to a volatile short squeeze. Furthermore, some analysts from Goldman Sachs believe that banks will demonstrate stability in deposit levels during the quarter, which could support certain banks. These factors, coupled with guidance on net interest income in the fourth quarter and beyond, could pave the way for a relief rally in an industry that has experienced significant declines.
The challenges faced by American banks, including shrinking margins and rising loan losses due to higher interest rates, present a difficult near-term outlook for the industry. However, there may be opportunities for certain banks to weather these challenges and potentially experience a relief rally. The impact of higher rates on banks’ earnings and balance sheets varies, and analysts’ predictions differ. The duration of banks’ bond holdings and potential loan losses are crucial factors to consider. Only time will tell how the industry will fare in the coming months.
Leave a Reply